Join my email list and get FREE ACCESS to the MSM Freebie Library, including my top printables & eBooks.

My Completely Honest Review of Stitch Fix (Take 2)

This post may contain affiliate links. Read my disclosure policy here.

My Completely Honest Review of Stitch Fix (Part Two) | I’ve gotten many, many questions about Stitch Fix over the past year and was hesitant to post about it again because it has been somewhat hit or miss for me. However, because of all the questions I’ve gotten, I decided it might be helpful for me to write another update with more information and share some additional tips that I’ve learned that might be helpful to some of you...

I’ve gotten many, many questions about Stitch Fix over the past year and was hesitant to post about it again because it has been somewhat hit or miss for me. However, because of all the questions I’ve gotten, I decided it might be helpful for me to write another update with more information and share some additional tips that I’ve learned that might be helpful to some of you.

Back when Stitch Fix first launched, a few of my friends signed up for it and loved it. Based upon their recommendation and my husband’s encouragement, I tried it out. That was a few years ago and I wasn’t thrilled with what I got in my box.

In fact, I sent half of it back, and I wish I wouldn’t have kept two of the items I did because as much as I thought I could convince myself to love them, I just couldn’t.

I did get a pair of earrings in the box that I love and have worn countless times since then. So that was the one redeeming part of my first Stitch Fix experience.

Why I Tried Stitch Fix Again

I decided that Stitch Fix just wasn’t for me and was happy to leave it at that. However, when a friend invited me to go with her to a Stitch Fix Influencer’s Dinner here in Nashville. I decided to go — mostly because I was honored to be asked and I was hopeful that I’d meet some other local bloggers at the event.

While at the Stitch Fix event, I had a long talk with the Stitch Fix folks. I was quite cynical about things and they patiently answered all my questions. They encouraged me to give Stitch Fix another try. They gave me some pointers on how to get a box that’s according to your style (they encouraged me to be really, really specific in what I asked for and also encouraged me to set up a Pinterest board with wardrobe ideas).

And then, they gave me a $20 Stitch Fix credit coupon so I could try the service without having to pay the $20 stylist fee. I debated whether or not I was brave enough to try again. I finally decided that it was worth a shot since it was so risk-free. Even if I sent everything back, I’d not be out anything out of pocket.

My Completely Honest Review of Stitch Fix

So I really put some time and effort into making sure my profile had very specific directives on it and I set up a Pinterest board with some outfit ideas. I was so excited to get my box in the mail. Unfortunately, I was once again very disappointed. You can see what I got in that box here (I ended up sending everything back).

I had earned some Stitch Fix credit and had gotten some tips from people who have had success with Stitch Fix on how to have more success with your fixes, so I decided to try again. I didn’t keep my hopes up, but was pleasantly surprised when I actually loved one of the pairs of pants they sent to me.

Since then, because I had some more credit to use, I’ve gotten a few more boxes and had more success — mostly when it comes to jeans and shorts. But I’ve also gotten a few shirts and dresses that I’ve loved, as well.

How Stitch Fix works:

1. Sign up for a Stitch Fix account.

2. Fill out your style profile. You’ll give very specific details on sizes you wear, styles you like, colors you like, types of clothes you like, and what types of clothing you are specifically looking for (more casual, all business, a mix of both, etc.) You can be very detailed in your descriptions and even share a Pinterest board with them to give Stitch Fix some ideas of your tastes in clothing.

3. Go to checkout and pay a $20 styling fee (this is reimbursed if you choose to keep any of the clothes).

4. One of the Stitch Fix stylists will take your style profile, sizes, and preferences and put together a box of clothing based upon what they think you’ll like and what they think will work well for you.

5. They’ll send you this box in the mail. You’ll have a few days to go through the box, try on the clothes, and then choose to keep any that you liked and ship back any that didn’t work (they provide a postage-paid envelope for you to use).

Screenshot 2016-09-01 14.04.54

Tips To Get a Fix That Fits Your Style

Make Sure You Fill Out Your Style Profile Carefully — Be really, really honest in your style profile. Make sure all your sizing and preferences are absolutely accurate.

Request a Stylist — If you know someone who has gotten fixes that you especially love, you can ask them who their stylist is and you can request that they assign the same stylist to you. No guarantees, but I’ve heard of this working for people. You can also request to have the same stylist you had last time (if you liked them) or a different stylist (if you didn’t like what they chose).

Leave a Note For Your Stylist — Please do this. Tell your stylist exactly what you are looking for and what you aren’t looking for. They do read these notes and try to honor them.

Give Incredibly Honest Feedback — Seriously, don’t shy away here. I’m brutally honest and I’ve seen that it makes a huge difference when I leave 100% honest feedback. Don’t hold back!

Stick With it For a Few Fixes — It took several fixes for my stylist to really get what I liked. I’m very picky on the clothes I keep. Since I have a minimalist wardrobe, I have to really love a piece of clothing to keep it. As the stylists learn your fashion tastes and what you don’t like, they will do a better job choosing for you. After I had done several fixes with them, I noticed that they were sending me fixes that were much more in line with my style.

Request Multiples of An Item You Liked — If you liked a specific dress, shirt, or pair of shorts, you can ask if they have it in any other colors. I’m the kind of person who loves to get multiples of the same style (it simplifies things!), so this has worked well for me! (For instance, I got multiples of this dress and these pair of shorts — just in different colors.)

My Completely Honest Review of Stitch Fix

Here are my overall thoughts on the Pros & Cons of Stitch Fix:


  • It’s insightful to fill out your style profile! It helps you think through what you love and what you don’t love.
  • It’s fun to anticipate getting a box in the mail! It’s fairly rare that I get to open and go through a mystery box, so looking forward to the box makes the experience more exciting!
  • Since I don’t enjoy shopping, I love getting a box of pre-chosen clothes in the mail — SO much easier than going shopping! Plus, I loved being able to try them on my own bathroom, see if they match items I own already, and decide whether I want to keep them or send them back.
  • I love the styling cards they gave you with each of the items to give you ideas of how to accessories a piece/what to wear it with. These are great especially for someone like me who has no idea how to put outfits together. (See examples of the Style Profile cards here.)
  • It’s great to be challenged to try new things. Many of the items they send are styles I wouldn’t pick off the rack at the store, so it’s great to have the opportunity to try on new and different styles. It’s caused me to be a little more adventuresome in what I wear.

My Completely Honest Review of Stitch Fix


  • You never know what you’re going to get. A few times, I’ve loved almost every piece in my fix. Other times, I’ve loathed most of what was sent. It’s a risk you’re taking — and you’re out $20 if none of the items work for you. (See my fix below for proof of that.)
  • Sometimes, it seems like they don’t look at your style profile carefully — or they are limited on options they have to send in your size and preferences. I’ve had a few times where I wondered if they stylist even so much as glanced at my profile because what she sent was so, so different than what I was also disappointed because I had been very detailed in exactly what I was looking for.
  • The prices at Stitch Fix are going to be much more than you’re going to find at the thrift store or on the sales rack. This service is designed specifically for women aren’t on a extremely tight budget who want to dress fashionably without spending a lot of time shopping. For busy working women, it could be a lifesaver. However, I think you need to be somewhat adventurous for it to work well for you.

My Completely Honest Review of Stitch Fix

{These shorts were one of my favorite pieces in a fix from last year. I get asked all the time where they are from! I ended up getting them in khaki and turquoise because I loved them so much!}

Read My Completely Honest Review of Stitch Fix here and read Why I May Have Changed My Mind About Stitch Fix here. 

Have you tried Stitch Fix before? If so, I’d love to hear what you thought of it.

Subscribe for free email updates from Money Saving Mom® and get my Guide to Freezer Cooking for free!


  • Stacy says:

    To be brutally honest, this service seems like it’s taking a big risk if you aren’t lucky enough to get free credit for recommending it to people. I can’t imagine spending $20 to get nothing for it. I’m a little curious why you keep trying it over and over again when it seems like you’ve had little luck picking items.

    • I’ve actually had some GREAT experiences with it — you can see one of the pair of shorts I got that I LOVED here: I usually keep at least one item from every one of my fixes and a lot of the shorts and jeans I wear are from Stitch Fix.

      I’ve shared some of my other unboxing on FB Live and I’ve gotten SO many questions that I wanted to do an updated post with updated information since so many people have asked for more details and it’s been awhile since I’ve done a post.

      I’ve only sent everything back twice, actually, if I’m remembering correctly. But I want to be really, really honest in my posts so that I’m not promoting it in a way that might hype it up to be something that it’s not.

  • Joy says:

    I have tried Stitch Fix and love it. However, it is a lot of money to invest in clothing at one time. I decided that I just cannot afford $50 an item. However, I do see myself using it again if I am unable to find any clothing through Thred Up or in my local community, just not on a regular basis. I love the clothing and convenience of it! It would be more affordable to just buy one item but I usually love everything in my box and it is tempting especially with the discount not to buy the whole box. Lol.

  • Elizabeth says:

    I have a friend who started at a job at a new company and was amazed at how put together the women looked. She asked around and found out that a number of them were using Stitch Fix

    When I’ve looked at some of the styles I’ve decided it probably isn’t for me. I also have a fairly minimalist wardrobe and have two go to stores that I can order online. I have however recently came across a service that puts together outfits that you can buy and may give that a try.

    Probably the one benefit of using a service like this is the put together look you can achieve.

  • Michelle Quam says:

    I just got my first box yesterday. I was so excited. I don’t buy a lot of clothes. If I do, they are the same style and color and wanted help in trying new things. I got a pair of jeans that I loved. They are so comfortable that I could sleep in them and they fit perfectly. I also kept a dressy shirt. i returned 3 items. The necklace that was in my box in my opinion looked cheap for the price and had a tassel. Not my cup of tee. I am looking forward to my next box next month.

  • Lana says:

    I tried it & really disliked it. Maybe my hopes were set too high, but the clothes were not me at all. They had sent black for summer clothes (?), the pants they sent were way too short though I told them my inseam/size/height, etc. Basically, for me, it was a waste of $20. I wouldn’t mind the cost if it was for clothes I liked, but I really didn’t. I had given what I thought were specifics as to what I liked/didn’t like & I had posted on Pinterest outfits I liked. I wouldn’t try it again unless it was completely risk free like you had. I’ve heard a lot of other people like it though & I’m glad it worked out for them.

  • Dara says:

    I initially had a good experience with Stitch Fix. (My one initial complaint was that all the clothes I’ve received were hand wash only!)

    When I started up again after my pregnant weight was gone, I got a different stylist and it was summer instead of winter. Being a modest, conservative type, I specifically requested shirts that had sleeves and were not see-through. (Who wants to layer when it’s 100F outside?!). They looked at those comments because they mentioned them in my note from stylist, but still sent me everything I asked NOT to receive! I sent everything back and left negative commentary on the fix review and sent the company an email. (All my commentary was polite – I’m not a troll!). No response at all! I won’t be using them again which is sad because I would buy my complete fix every month if it meant I never had to go shopping again!

  • Aimee says:

    I’ve enjoyed reading your posts about Stitch Fix. It doesn’t currently work for our budget but I’m keeping it in mind for when I return to work someday!

  • Lynn says:

    I so wanted to try stitch fix. One of my co-workers purchased from them and I really like what she ended up with. I am a more curvy woman and the service didn’t offer anything at all in my size. Therefore, I haven’t been able to try. After the reviews, I think I may be okay with that.

  • Nicole says:

    I have used Stitch Fix for over a year now. I absolutely love the ease of the service. Even if I send everything back, it’s still $20 well spent. How many times have I gotten a babysitter, gone to the mall to find nothing, and wasted the whole afternoon?! That’s more than $20 right there.

    I have been INCREDIBLY disappointed with my last few fixes. The quality of the SF branded clothing has gone waaaaayyyyyyy down. I have shirts that are unraveling and shrinking even though I hand wash them. In fact, I am going to send an email today about a dress that shrank after hand washing. Their name brand clothing (Kut from the Kloth, etc.) has been fine, of course.

  • Kirsten says:

    I have been using stich fix for over a year and I love it! The last two boxes I have kept everything in it. My stylist knows what I like and were to try something new and most times I love it. One thing is that I use Pintrest ALOT so holly can see what I am loving for the season. In fact most of my clothes are from stich fix.

  • Kacie says:

    I’ve really enjoyed stitch fix. I’ve been blessed with some gift cards for Christmas and my birthday which helped me get some cute maternity clothes. I think if I didn’t work it wouldn’t be worth it because of the cost, but I’m happy with the quality pieces I’ve received.

  • Lisa says:

    I tried Stitch Fix twice and was disappointed both times. After the second time I asked that the styling fee be refunded since it was clear they weren’t at all paying attending to either my style board on Pinterest or my specific requests (i.e. no sleeveless tops or dresses which resulted in them sending me a box with four sleeveless items). At first they said no but I’ll give them credit that when I pushed they eventually refunded the fee. That was nice of them. Although it did irritate me to be told I needed to increase my price points when I said that $70 was too much to pay for an acrylic cardigan or a rayon long sleeve tee.

    After my experience I came to two conclusions about Stitch Fix.

    The first is that there really is one Stitch Fix style. Even though there are multiple options on the style profile they have you fill out, looking around the internet for blog articles about Stitch Fix it’s clear they aren’t offering clothing of vastly different styles. The clothes are cute if they fit you well (which they didn’t for me) and if they are your style but there really aren’t as many options as they have you believe.

    The second is that bloggers who write about their experiences are getting different clothes than the rest of us. Maybe I’m being unfair but both times I scoured the internet to see what was in other people’s boxes and found the clothes to be much better than what I was given. Especially the first box where it seemed like they hadn’t even glanced at my style profile.

    I can see why people like Stitch Fix but after trying them twice I became disillusioned and gave up.

  • Jennifer says:


    I just appreciate the fact that you are so real and honest about your experiences and don’t just sugarcoat – or lie – to make money. I read several blogs and feel that’s how they operate.

  • Liza says:

    I love Stitch Fix as well as my daughter. I hate shopping, I hate trying stuff on in a store, this works well for me. I’m hard to fit due to my chest size (38DDD) and I like to dress creatively, but professional. I’m always getting pieces that I feel great in. I’m very specific. I love my stylist, I had others at the beginning that were trying to dress me like an old lady, this one gets it, and I put in the note not to switch me, even if a fix didn’t work out (often due to my chest size, not the style.) She’s styled me based on activities I tell her about such as vacations, seminars or business trips and she did an awesome job when I broke my ankle, (cute pants that fit over the cast and over-the-shoulder bags to use with crutches.) I’ve only had a piece or two that I ruined washing the wrong way by accident.

  • Carrie says:

    I agree with your comments here Crystal. The price points are higher than I would normally pay, but with 7 kids, getting out shopping is SO difficult that I find myself with no decent clothing from time to time. I use Stitch fix to supplement my frugal thrift store finds.

    Also I hate shopping!

    My fixes have been hit and miss, but I have some pieces that are now among my absolute favorites.

  • Jackie says:

    Is it a one time stylist fee or do you pay it with each box?

  • Heather says:

    i just received my first fix and I love it!

    I’m going back to work after home schooling for 15 years and really need everything. I did spend lots of time answering the questions, left extensive notes for the stylist and set up a pintrest board. There was only one piece I wasn’t crazy about, but I would wear it and I wanted the 25% discount.

    They sent a pair of Cole Haan pumps that I absolutely LOVE, and I thought price was good. I live in a small town and am 1 hour away from a mall AND I hate to shop, so I I hope Stitch fix works for me! Thank you for your review Crystal…it really helped me.

  • Ann says:

    The first box I got I was surprised at the expense and didn’t realize I was going to lose the $20 if I sent everything back. I wish I had kept the jacket. Lesson learned. The last two boxes that I’ve gotten I’ve loved. I am a stay at home mom and shopping with kids is not easy. My husband is actually the one who told me to spend the money. So it’s my splurge on myself. I rarely spend that kind of money on clothes, but my stylist clearly looks at t Pinterest board and profile so I’ve loved almost everything. I tack the cards on the wall in my closet for future ideas. It’s really helped me have some confidence in styling.

  • Debbie says:

    I got my first Stitch Fix earlier this year and although this is an old post I hope I can share my experience. My first box, I kept a dress and a pair of jeans. I wore the dress for Easter and love it. The jeans, I wore for a month and realized that they looked sloppy and were not worth the money I spent on them. I wrote to the company and they were happy to refund me the money and sent me a prepaid label via email that I printed. It didn’t cost me anything to send them back. My second box came and I was EXTREMELY disappointed. I had asked for no sleeveless blouses and all 5 items in the box were sleeveless. I sent it all back and wrote a detailed letter. They apologized and credited me the $20 for my next fix. Since then, I wore a pair of shorts for a few weeks and decided I needed one size smaller. They didn’t have them and they offered me a full refund and sent the prepaid label. I think they have Excellent customer service. I asked for a cold shoulder blouse this last time and I got one. I can usually only afford to keep one item or two but it is so fun and helps me build a couple of quality pieces. Thanks, just wanted to share.

  • Tiffany says:

    I get my Stitch fix quarterly. (At first I got every other month because I lost 40 pounds and no clothes fit anymore – YAY!) I have a great designer that reads my comments and really has captured my style well. At first the picks were a little above my cost range, but my stylist found clothes that fit my preferences in a range I feel comfortable splurging on myself every few months. Feedback with your designer is important. I actually log onto my account ahead of time and answer their questions of “would you wear this” type of feedback they need. Plus, buying the entire box at once with the 25% off (minus the style credit too) makes this affordable. I am a busy Mom so going shopping for myself is more of a nuisance trying to squeeze it in so this is great for me! The last box I received there was only one top I wasn’t crazy over, but it was less expensive to buy the entire box. I ended up wearing the shirt and liked it on better than in the box. 🙂 I have not tried other type of boxes to compare it to, but I really like my stylist here. I won’t be leaving any them any time soon. (Note: my friend that turned me onto Stitch Fix did not leave any feedback with her stylist and she ended up stopping her shipments due to being unhappy with her shipments. She kept seeing all of my clothing and saying – “well I would wear that if they would have sent me that” or “that’s what I wanted them to send.” I told her I left regular feedback so I could be catered to. She said she may try again now that she realizes the importance of the communication.) Overall a great experience. I don’t always LOVE everything that is sent, but a majority of the time – it’s darn pretty close. 🙂

Money Saving Mom® Comment Policy

We love comments from readers, so chime in with your thoughts below! We do our best to keep this blog upbeat and encouraging, so please keep your comments cordial and kind. Read more information on our comment policy.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *