Want to Make a Full-Time Income From Home?
Sign up for my Free 5-Day Course!
Just type in your name and email address below and I'll get you signed up for this 5-day course—for FREE!

Frugal Fail: The Terrible, Horrible, No-Good, Very Bad Waffle Experiment

My dad gave an illustration in his sermon last Sunday and part of it referred to “his daughter who never follows recipes and is known for making up all sorts of interesting concoctions as a result.”

My husband turned and looked at me during the sermon with a smirk on his face. He knows all too well about my “interesting concoctions”.

Back when I was living at home, my poor family was subjected to all sorts of my failed experiments and to this day, I think they are afraid to eat my cooking. However, I have improved over time and, gratefully, mishaps are fairly rare occurrences these days.

This week, though, I think my waffle experiment topped some of the worst kitchen fails I’ve had in my history of cooking. Yes, it was bad.

The recipe looked so simple and delicious. How could you go wrong with brownies and bananas in waffles?

Well, let me tell you, you can go wrong with brownies and bananas and waffles. Very, very wrong.

It started off on a bad footing when I decided to substitute the Homemade Baking Mix in place of the flour, sugar, baking powder and salt. I added in the cocoa powder, cinnamon, and wheat germ, then I mixed together the milk, bananas, and eggs.

That was when I got stumped. You see, the Homemade Baking Mix has coconut oil already in it. So I realized I probably didn’t need the oil.

But after I mixed the wet ingredients in with the dry ingredients, I noticed big chunks of coconut oil in the batter. And it struck me that that could be a problem.

Not easily deterred, I pressed on, heated the waffle iron, and poured some batter on it. The batter looked unlike any other waffle batter consistency I’d seen before and I became a little concerned.

The first waffle wouldn’t even come off the waffle iron without lots of effort — and it ended up breaking into a hundred pieces in the process. “Oh well, the first waffle is always the worst,” I told myself.

But then I decided to taste-test it. It was disgusting.

I thought maybe it just needed more sugar, so added more sugar and poured more waffle batter on. The second waffle was even worse — and it still tasted gross. There were white chunks in it (coconut oil?) and it fell apart in dozens of pieces while I tried to get it off the iron.

I decided to give up on the waffle idea and began wracking my brain to see what I could instead turn this icky batter into. “Pancakes!”, I thought. “I’ll make pancakes with it!”

But the pancakes I tried to make with it were gooey and crumbling and tasted terrible. The kids wouldn’t eat them — even with coaxing. And I’m guessing if we had a dog, he wouldn’t have eaten it either.

I finally gave up and threw out all the waffle and pancake pieces as well as the batter. It was a lost cause.

The good news? The Double Chocolate Oatmeal Muffins I made during that same cooking session (and, of course, tweaked the recipe for) actually turned out beautifully and delicious.

So I think there still may be hope for this experimental cook, but I know it’s going to take me a few months to work up the courage to try experimenting with a waffle recipe again!

Share This:

Subscribe for free email updates from Money Saving Mom® and get my Guide to Freezer Cooking for free!

Read Newer Post
Read Older Post


  1. says

    I tried to do waffles with dried cherries in them one time. SO didn’t work well with the waffle maker. Sticky, chewy cherries smoking on the waffle iron so not appetizing. They did make good pancakes though. :)

  2. Laura says

    Thanks so much for sharing you freezer friendly recipes. They have been time savers for me this summer. We have tried the recipes for baked oatmeal, breakfast burritos, protein bars, southwest roll-ups, ww choc. chip pancakes, ww choc. chip oatmeal cookies, and worlds easiest make ahead marinated chicken. I added a breakfast sandwiches, applesauce muffins and breakfast cookies to my freezer cooking list also. Everything was a hit with my husband and three very picky kids. My husband loves being able to go to the freezer and give the kids a homemade breakfast. No more poptarts in this house. Thanks again for sharing.

  3. Sarah says

    These sounded so good, I had to try the original recipe and learn from your mistake and follow the recipe exactly! I have to say, it might be destined to fail. I made 2 batches, one with wheat germ and one without, because I suspected my wheat germ might not be good. Neither batch was very good. I froze the leftovers and my two year old recoiled in terror this morning-NO CHOCOLATE WAFFLES!! NOT THE CHOCOLATE WAFFLES!

Money Saving Mom® Comment Policy

We love comments from readers, so chime in with your thoughts below! We do our best to keep this blog upbeat and encouraging, so please keep your comments cordial and kind. Read more information on our comment policy.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *